Beautiful Caitlyn Jenner and Christian Ugliness

Caitlyn Jenner in Vanity Fair

Caitlyn Jenner in Vanity Fair

Over on Facebook I have been hearing about a wave of ugliness coming from people reacting to Caitlyn Jenner. A lot of the derision is from some Christian folks. While I am not terribly surprised by this–I had been an Evangelical Fundamentalist anti-LGBTQ Christian myself for many years, even as I tried to suppress my rabid gayness–I am amazed at how ignorant people can be about the scripture they profess to follow.

Many eunuchs were castrated before puberty--they retained high voices and did not develop the facial hair, body hair, and muscle that come with testosterone. They were sexual and gender minorities.

Many eunuchs were castrated before puberty–they retained high voices and did not develop the facial hair, body hair, and muscle that come with testosterone. They were sexual and gender minorities.

For instance. Do you know about the the first baptism in the fledgling church as recorded in Acts chapter 8? The writer of Acts went out of the way to point out that this first baptism was of a Black, African, surgically-altered, gender-variant, wealthy, literate, civil servant who is a person of faith. To the poorer, illiterate, non-eunuch early church folks, this Ethiopian Eunuch is the ultimate outsider. Yet this is the first baptism.

Of course a eunuch did not usually get to choose to be a eunuch. This identity was forced on them against their will often when they were quite young. What stands out though is not only that they are part of so many Bible stories (and there are many eunuch stories in the Bible) but these sexual and gender minorities are essential to the Bible stories in which they appear. For Christians trying to wrap their heads around gender issues, especially when someone doesn’t fit neatly into traditional boxes, eunuch stories might be a way to open up to new ideas.

People react to difference and change in lots of ways. Some people are shocked when they see someone embrace a different identity. And I totally understand some of the pushback when it comes to Caitlyn Jenner. There are the Kardashians of course and the industry they created promoting themselves along with the parallel cultural pastime that sprung up where people in the media, social media, and over brunch roundly mock the Kardashians. It is a dysfunctional relationship that it seems no one really wants to quit.

Susan Govatos Joseph's Dreams

Susan Govatos Joseph’s Dreams

So with the Kardashian reality TV machine there are people crowing, “But Bruce Jenner coming out as a woman is just a publicity stunt.” Well duh, she has a show she is promoting. There is publicity of course. We are talking about Hollywood, TV, and Vanity Fair here. Yes this is a well-orchestrated media sustained media event. But it is not a just a stunt to come out as a woman after decades of being known as one of America’s greatest male athletes. Anyone who listens to Jenner for two minutes can hear her sincerity. She has found her voice at last after years of shifting around in the shadows of reality TV.

I completely understand the important critique leveled by some trans people about  Jenner’s public coming out, rightly pointing out that most females who transition from male do not have the power, prestige, privilege, and money that Caitlyn has to aid in transition and acceptance in society. This is an essential and healthy argument led by people with transgender experiences. The criticism that I find questionable and inappropriate is by people who are not transgender and who use religion to justify being mean and thoughtless with their words.

Before Christians start jumping on a predictable and tiresome bandwagon of no, No, NO–Caitlyn Jenner is wrong (or worse), I suggest they take a look at one of the Bible’s most celebrated heroes. Dig into the story, look at the original language, and discover Joseph in the book of Genesis. There is more to this story than you may know. Like with most of us today, Joseph has a gender story. You will find that this version of the story of Joseph is completely supported by the Bible. To those who have ears to hear, let them hear.


This post has 6 Comments

  1. Gwen on June 4, 2015 at 11:02 am Reply

    I love you, Peterson! You are a wonderful, beautiful voice in the world. Thank you for being yourself.

  2. Paul Bergmann on June 11, 2015 at 5:34 pm Reply

    Peterson ive never seen or heard of you till this moment. I’ve pastored my church for the past 18 yrs. it’s been an evolving journey as it should be. When I took this position the church was extremely conservative politically and theologically fundamentalist. I don’t blame anyone, not even myself for what happened. My understanding of Jesus causes me to constantly question. My view on the death penalty, war, economics, patriotism, history, sexual orientation, scripture, hell, heaven continually changed with study, education and conversation with the “other!” I survived public and private heresy trials, mass exodus of members, church splits and public scorn. It’s not been because of great character so much as a inability on my behalf to be anything but honest with who I am. Many times I wished I could have just faked it for my family and my own preservation. But I couldn’t, and my family would never want me to be anything else. I Have no regrets. Our community still thrives but with a different atmosphere altogether. It’s a place where Catyln Jenner would be welcome. That’s my public message this Sunday. Thank you for your heart, teaching, grace and encouragement to me. I just had to tell you. Peace, grace, strength, love. Paul

  3. Peterson Toscano
    Peterson Toscano on June 12, 2015 at 8:33 am Reply

    Paul, thank you for taking the time to leave your comment. I appreciate the thoughtful words. It sounds like you have taken the responsibility of your ministry very seriously, allowing yourself to learn and grow. Thank you for that.
    All the best!

  4. Janice Brantner on June 12, 2015 at 8:05 pm Reply

    I also just heard of you for the first time today, and I want to hear so much more from you. Great post, and I love the Jospeh video so much! Isn’t it amazing that such a man is used as a type of Jesus, with so many of Joseph’s life events corresponding to events in the life of Jesus!

    • Peterson Toscano
      Peterson Toscano on June 13, 2015 at 8:20 am Reply

      Janice, that is great to hear. How did you hear about this post? If you want to hear more like this, check out my YouTube page

  5. Janice Brantner on June 18, 2015 at 7:42 pm Reply

    It was shared on Christians For Humble Dialogue. I am a member of this group. It seems the post was shared by you. Are you a member also?

Leave a Comment